You’re either a Beatles man or an Elvis man. You’re either a Marvel man or a DC man. Full disclosure, I am a Marvel man. That doesn’t mean I hate DC. It means I was raised on Spider-Man and The Punisher and The Fantastic Four. So, my sensibilities make me root more for Marvel to succeed than DC. However, there are certain heroes in each company that supersede bias. For Marvel it would be Spider-Man. For DC it is The Dark Knight.
I have loved this trilogy. Even though Chris Nolan does tear away and dismiss nearly all the things that make Batman a comic book character in exchange for realism. A gamble that worked. A gamble that could ONLY…ONLY work for Batman. (DO YOU HEAR ME YOU TWO?) Nothing flashy…nothing fun….bleak….realism….and we ate it up. But it wasn’t the realism that sold Nolan’s Batman to me. It was his world building. His scope. Making everything seem so GRAND yet keeping it contained mostly in one city. Gotham City. The name I would have called this movie over The Dark Knight Rises. This film isn’t really about Batman to me. Its about Gotham. Batman is barely in it. And we see how a city tries to survive and hold out without him. When the sh*t started hitting the fan in this movie, I kept muttering to myself…”This looks like a job for Superman.” or “Where is the Justice League?” But Nolan isolated this trilogy into the loneliness of realism to not have to worry about those things. He wanted it to be about Gotham City. That, to me, is the point of The Dark Knight Rises. The point of the entire trilogy. A symbol giving a city’s citizens strength to protect themselves. To rise up and be their own heroes. And in that regard, Nolan knocks it out of the park.
No. Its not perfect. No. Its not better than The Dark Knight. No. I didn’t like it better than Avengers. But Yes. It is a must watch. For GRANDNESS alone it is a must watch. You will feel the hopelessness and uncertainty of who is going to save the day right along with Gotham’s citizens. You will love everything Joseph Gordan Levitt does. Though there is a final bit with him that is a little hit or miss with avid comic book fans. You will wonder what the hell Bane is saying sometimes but will never wonder how dangerous and scary he is. You will realize that in a film of terrifically portrayed bleakness, Anne Hathaway’s scenes as Selina Kyle are probably the only ones that feel fun. You will be saddened as a DC fan at the end when it dawns on you that Warner Brothers will now attempt to tear this entire trilogy down to reboot the franchise.
The Dark Knight Rises is probably the only way you could end this series. By itself, if we knew more were coming in this universe, it would be worth nitpicking. But as a denouement to probably one of the GRANDEST trilogies since The Lord Of The Rings, it rises to the occasion. Christopher Nolan made Batman into Lawrence Of Arabia. And for that, we should thank him. Watch it…then tell me I’m wrong.